• Policy & Research
    • Campus Climate and Inclusion
    • Minority Serving Institutions
    • Student Support and Success
  • Leadership
    • The ACE Women’s Network
  • International
  • Attainment & Innovation

Bridging Divides, Public Work: A Call to Action for Higher Education

October 16, 2020

By Derek W. M. Barker and Harry C. Boyte


To put it mildly, the American electoral system is troubled. The republican system of government was designed to withstand and take advantage of our tendency to divide into factions, yet today the nation suffers from deep polarization, acrimony, and even hatred. A new poll by the group Braver Angels, featured Oct. 7 in USA Today and Newsweek, finds that a majority of Americans fear violence and crisis around the upcoming election. The current division also coincides with a concerning long-term decline in confidence in government and public institutions—including higher education.

Higher education has a crucial role to play in this troubled time, one which could help turn the dangers into opportunities for reconnection with civic life.

For decades, colleges and universities have had the conviction that they should stay neutral in politics. This narrow view of the role of higher education, informed by a shrunken view of politics as partisan warfare, is fed by many forces—narrow definitions of research, meritocratic views of higher education as a sorting mechanism, and incentive structures based on rankings that have increasingly detached higher education from society, among others.

For the most part, higher education has seen its civic role as preparing students to be informed citizens. The problem is than an informed citizenry can still be bitterly divided. Indeed, despite the rise of the internet and social media, arguably our citizenry is increasingly self-sorted into tribes. Rather than encouraging dialogue across differences, research suggests that higher education may actually reinforce students’ social bubbles.

We propose that higher education take this moment of division as an opportunity to recommit to understandings of colleges as civic centers for discussion and public work in the life of communities. The very notion of liberal education is centered on freedom from dogma and ideology, which entails robust public discussion across differences. These ideas were once widespread, especially in land-grant universities, Historically Black Colleges and Universities, and locally rooted private colleges. They fed into the Truman report in 1947, which declared that “The first and most essential charge upon higher education is that . . . it shall be the carrier of democratic values, ideals, and processes.”[1]

In this time of stress, higher education needs to reclaim its democratic role as bridge builder and commit to what might be called a “higher partisanship” beyond partisan warfare; that is, a forceful commitment to the democratic process itself without favoring any particular viewpoint.[2] Colleges and universities can educate future citizens in the skills and habits they will need to make decisions and work together with others of different backgrounds and perspectives. They can convene public discussions and frame issues for constructive dialogue. Research has shown that experiences in dialogue and deliberation can make significant impacts on future citizens’ attitudes towards politics.

Campuses around the country are seeing stirrings of this sort of civic engagement, conveying to students and others that democracy is far more than an electoral conflict. A coalition of higher education partners working with the National Issues Forums Institute has come together to convene dialogues on campuses around the country on controversial topics such as free speech and policing. Braver Angels, a citizen movement with the purpose of depolarizing America, has created an initiative called Hold American Together that asks Americans to eschew violence in the election whichever side it comes from.

These are signs of higher education remembering its role as “agents and architects”[3] of a democratic society. It has never been more relevant.


[1] President’s Commission on Higher Education, and George Frederick Zook, Higher Education for American Democracy: A Report (Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1947).

[2] See also Martín Carcasson’s work on passionate impartiality in “Rethinking Civic Engagement on Campus: The Overarching Potential of Deliberative Practice,” Higher Education Exchange (2013).

[3] Harry Boyte and Elizabeth Hollanderon, Wingspread Declaration on Renewing the Civic Mission of the American Research University (Boston, MA: Campus Compact, 1999).

Tags: civic engagement election 2020 leadership

One Response to “Bridging Divides, Public Work: A Call to Action for Higher Education”

  1. Cyndee Hyatt

    Outstanding Statement for Higher Education Leadership!
    I want to commend the contributors for their response to Community Engagement.
    Doctoral Researcher

    November 23rd, 2020 Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share this Post
Share this...
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Pin on Pinterest
Pinterest
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
Linkedin
About the Author
Harry C. Boyte

Harry Boyte is senior scholar in public work philosophy at Augsburg University, and co-director, with Marie Strom and Trygve Throntveit, of the Institute for Public Life and Work.

Derek W. M. Barker

Derek W. M. Barker is a program officer at the Kettering Foundation. With a background in political theory, he works primarily on research concerning the democratic role of higher education institutions; philanthropy and nonprofit organizations; journalism; and the professions.

More Information

Civic Engagement and Democracy: Special Focus on the 2020 Election

Recent posts
  • The College President’s Role During Times of Crisis
  • What Can Colleges and Universities Do to Support the Mental Health of Their Student-Athletes?
  • Course Sharing: Business Models and the Learning Ecosystem in Action
  • WISHES: A New Measurement Approach to Support Systemic Change in Student Wellbeing
  • Reimagining Higher Education: A New Campus in Colorado, Open to Everyone
See More

American Council on Education
1 Dupont Circle, NW
Washington, DC 20036

202-939-9300

  • About Us
  • Contributors
  • ACE In The News
  • Contact

Sign up for the ACE Newsletter

The latest news from ACE, including the most recent blog posts from Higher Education Today, free to your inbox each Tuesday.

Sign up to subscribe to Higher Education & National Affairs (HENA), ACE’s biweekly newsletter covering events in Washington that impact higher education and ACE’s activities in international education, leadership, research and analysis, and adult learning and attainment.

Sign Up


© 2023 American Council on Education. All Rights Reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use