• Policy & Research
    • Campus Climate and Inclusion
    • Student Support and Success
    • Minority Serving Institutions
  • Leadership
    • The ACE Women’s Network
  • International
  • Attainment & Innovation

Celebrating Democracy, No Matter the Outcome

October 16, 2020

By Darren Cambridge and Brad Farnsworth


The 2020 presidential election was bound to be controversial even before COVID-19, but the pandemic has made the stakes even higher. Campuses, normally centers for voter registration and other political events, are struggling to maintain a sense of normalcy or are physically closed altogether. The typical activities surrounding civic engagement in an election year must be carefully considered, either because of the limitations of social distancing or because of the fraught nature of today’s political and racial climates.

No matter which candidate wins, campus leaders have a role in maintaining civility, promoting civic engagement, and celebrating the democratic process. ACE’s Community of Practice on Civic Engagement and Democracy recently discussed how to make the election meaningful to students, regardless of the results. Composed of 45 members, the community of practice includes presidents, provosts, vice presidents, faculty, and nonprofit leaders from a variety of institutions. Together, they explored how campuses can prepare for the 2020 election, as well as a vision for success that focuses on student and institutional outcomes, not political wins.

Action steps for campus leaders

One thing the group made clear up front: In advance of the election, leaders can set the tone for a campus climate that respects and acknowledges the democratic process and the opinions of others. Integrating that message into campus communications creates safe and accessible environments for civic engagement for all students during any election season, but particularly this year.

Academic leaders also play a significant role in creating these environments. Provosts, deans, and chairs can cultivate a climate for political learning, including integrating election content into courses across disciplines and preparing students for post-election scenarios. Center directors can provide resources to inform students about voting and civic participation, with intentional strategies to reach underrepresented groups. Directors can also check in with students to ask about their response to different scenarios after the election and their would-be reactions to other campus groups. Leaders in intermediary organizations, such as associations and nonprofits, can also help, especially in providing resources and support on topics like voting, digital literacy, deliberative dialogue, and how students can learn from other groups and those with differing opinions.

Questions to ask during this period:

As a president: How can you encourage democracy on your campus using your leadership position and communication channels? Is your campus prepared for the days and weeks after the election?

As a member of the academic community: How can you integrate this election into your classroom discussion in a way that benefits student engagement and civil dialogue?

As a center director: Have you reached out to your student groups, encouraging individuals to vote (particularly underrepresented individuals)? Have you checked in with groups that might particularly need guidance after the election?

As a subject-matter expert at an intermediary organization: Have you reached out to your campus contacts to offer support and resources?

Success means democracy wins

In 2020, almost everyone seems to care deeply about who wins the presidential election, campus leaders included. It is difficult to have a vision for success that isn’t linked to a specific candidate’s victory. Nonetheless, we owe it to students to impart the importance of civic engagement and to teach them that a successful democratic process alone is a victory.

The Civic Engagement and Democratic Practices Community of Practice agreed that success can take many forms after the election. These outcomes are both goals to work toward and talking points for conversations with students after the election. While we are writing this post about a month in advance of the election, we imagine success on November 4 might include these scenarios:

  • During this election, students led, organized, and felt engaged. The election was an opportunity for students to show leadership and get out the vote. It has and will continue to be a time to connect policy and theory to issues and action.
  • The campus community saw widespread democratic discourse, making room for a diversity of views.
  • Polling was safe and smooth: no one felt targeted for their ideas, and the checks and balances of power worked. Moreover, people trusted that their votes were counted.
  • More citizens—especially students—voted than this year than in previous elections, and access to good information and training about how to vote was readily available. (ACE recently released a brief on Student Voting and College Political Campaign-Related Activities in 2020 that might be helpful.)
  • Historically underrepresented groups sought representation, made their voice heard in this election, and brought the need for equity to the national conversation.
  • Campus leaders communicated their commitment to democracy and civic engagement, using campus communications to encourage students to participate.
  • The campus community supported students after the election. A post-election plan is in place to help students process events and outcomes productively.

No matter the outcome, students can benefit from understanding democratic ideas, and as a campus leader, you can help students recognize and celebrate democracy. Our nation needs a future generation that believe that democracy trumps any one political party.

Tags: civic engagement election 2020 leadership

One Response to “Celebrating Democracy, No Matter the Outcome”

  1. James

    I agree. Underrepresented groups turning out to vote is a success.

    December 1st, 2020 Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share this Post
Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
Linkedin
About the Author
Brad Farnsworth

Brad Farnsworth is vice president for internationalization and global engagement for ACE. He is responsible for several programs, including the Internationalization Collaborative, the Institute for Leading Internationalization, and engagement with the Washington-based diplomatic community. He is also responsible for implementing the Center’s fundraising strategy. From 1991 until joining ACE in early 2012, Farnsworth was director… Read more »

Darren Cambridge

Darren Cambridge is director of content strategy for ACE Engage, a community of higher education leaders with a mission to share expertise, learn, and collaborate.

More Information

More resources on democracy on campus

Civic Engagement and Democracy: Special Focus on the 2020 Election

Key Leadership Actions to Prepare Our Campuses for the Election [Webinar on ACE Engage—create your complimentary account]

The Practices of Freedom: Freedom of Speech, Academic Freedom, and Shared Governance [Video]

Crisis Planning: How to Prepare for Free Speech Conflicts on Campus [Video]

You may Also be Interested In
  • Why Social Interactions Matter for Our Conversations About Campus Climates and STEM
  • Western Governors University, Ohio Community Colleges Collaborate to Meet Needs of Adult Students
  • Deconstructing CBE: A Different Approach
  • SDSU and Rio Salado College Empowering Student Veterans to Succeed, On and Off Campus
See More

American Council on Education
1 Dupont Circle, NW
Washington, DC 20036

202-939-9300

  • About Us
  • Contributors
  • ACE In The News
  • Contact

Sign up for the ACE Newsletter

The latest news from ACE, including the most recent blog posts from Higher Education Today, free to your inbox each Tuesday and Thursday.

Sign up to subscribe to Higher Education & National Affairs (HENA), ACE’s biweekly newsletter covering events in Washington that impact higher education and ACE’s activities in international education, leadership, research and analysis, and adult learning and attainment.

Sign Up


© 2021 American Council on Education. All Rights Reserved.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use